I did soy milk and whey protein shakes with frozen strawberries, also slimfast until I was so sick of it, slimfast bars, cookies.  I would do great until there was a plate of donuts or cake or cookies at work, or my husband came home with his dinner, or a loaf of french bread.  Then, being hungry, my willpower finally caved in.  I also did ok, and was set to go for surgery then the date was rescheduled.  I went out and celebrated that I wasn't starting on the 2 wkk post surgery liquids.  So I gained back some I had lost.  This week, scheduled again, now for Nov 1st this is what I did.  I went on a total pinneaple binge for 2 days.  A little dried pinneaple and 3 large cans of pinneapple juice over 2 days.  Then I did the Hollywood miracle diet, but I drank all that juice in one day.  Then on the 4th day I took magnesium citrate laxative and ate very little.  I was back on the protein shakes (3) today.  I discovered a really tasty very low cal soup I can mix up at work.  1 can of low sodium V8 and 3 teaspoons of Gayelord Hauser natural vegetable broth.  It counteracts the desire for something not sweet.   I so wish diet products were not all sweet.  As of yesterday I had lost 7.5 lbs.  Not quite the goal but maybe a little more today and hope it will be enough.